So much hilarity, but no replayability.
When we first received this game, we were stoked to have a new addition to our collection, especially knowing it was written and illustrated by The Oatmeal himself. We gathered together our Mormon parents and my brother, forewarning them that 17+ for a game made by Exploding Kittens could mean anything from butts, to boobs, to some choice F-bombs being dropped. With that disclaimer noted, we headed to therapy.
We too turns reading the cards, laughing hysterically at the drawings of decapitated depictions and talk of pork nipples in our taco meat....
Between the 6 of us, the game, dinner and dessert, it took around 4 hours to finish. Everyone had a great time, even with the bird vaginas and having to explain to my poor mother in law what "phallic" means.
Overall, the evening was awesome and the game was so much fun! The puzzles can get quite tricky and we had to resort to reading all the hints on a few to get through it. We were constantly either overthinking or under thinking.
The main "gripe", if it's even a gripe, is that you can only play it ONCE. So now we have a kick ass game that'll sit and collect dust, unless we glue envelopes back together and reset it for someone else during a White Elephant party.
Also, my mom in law says she could've gone without so many bombs of the F variety, but hey, that all part and parcel for a wholesome Sunday bloody Sunday.
Good luck!